• HOME
  • Planning
    • Planner Newbie
      • New to planning? Start here
    • Planning Tips & Inspiration
    • 52 Planning Systems in 52 Weeks
      • My weekly spreads
    • Planner Index
    • Planner Reviews
      • Horizontal Weekly
      • Horizontal 1 Page Weekly + Notes
      • Vertical Weekly
      • Hourly Planners
      • Categories Weekly
      • Daily Planners
      • Discbound Planners
      • Teacher Planners
      • Planner Roundups
      • Happy Planner (MAMBI)
      • Budget Planners
    • Planner Comparisons
    • Bullet Journal
      • Bullet Journal Reviews
      • Bullet Journal Spreads
      • Bullet Journal Tips
    • Planner pens
    • Highlighters
    • Planner Stickers
    • Digital Planning
    • Household Binder
    • Stationery Shopping
    • Rachael’s Favorites
    • Blogging & Online Business
  • Graphic Design
    • Photoshop Tutorials
    • Microsoft Word
    • Microsoft Excel
    • Canva
    • Silhouette Studio
    • PicMonkey
  • SHOP
    • Shop at Etsy
    • Online Store
    • Graphic Design Resources
    • ECOURSES
    • Ebooks
      • 54 Mistakes Etsy Sellers Make (And How to Fix Them)
      • 1200 Blog Post Ideas
        • 1200 Blog Post Ideas (Exclusive Download Content)
      • 200 Blog Post Title Prompts (For Any Type of Blog)
        • 200 Blog Post Title Prompts (Exclusive Download Content)
    • Feedback & Testimonials
    • Planner Supplies (my sister’s shop!)
    • Shop my favorite planner supplies on Amazon
  • Learn
    • ECOURSES
      • Free Graphic Design Video Tutorials Library
      • How to Make Planner Stickers
      • How to Make Printables in Photoshop
      • How to Make Printables in Microsoft Word
      • How to Make Printables in Microsoft Excel
      • How to make digital planners and notebooks in Microsoft PowerPoint
      • How to Make Labels in Photoshop
      • How to Make Patterns in Photoshop
      • How to Make Party Printables
      • How to Write Product Descriptions
    • Ebooks
      • 54 Mistakes Etsy Sellers Make (And How to Fix Them)
      • 200 Blog Post Title Prompts (For Any Type of Blog)
      • 1200 Blog Post Ideas
  • FREE
    • FREE Printables
    • Free Printables Library – Subscribers Login
  • Travel
    • Travel Planning
    • Europe
    • Australia & New Zealand
  • About
    • Browse All Posts
    • FAQ
      • What is a Printable? What happens when I purchase a printable from you?
      • Printing Tips
      • Printable Planner Stickers
      • Downloading Files
      • How to Open Zipped File Folders
      • What does EDITABLE mean?
      • Monogram Etiquette

All About Planners

Printable planners to organize your home, business and life!

June 11, 2020

Plum Paper versus SHP Planners (Detailed Comparison)

Plum Paper is one of my favorite planner companies but their colors and style hasn’t changed for years. If you’re in need of a refresh and are looking for something similar to Plum Paper, the SHP Planner comes close.

SHP Planners versus Plum Paper

Information current as of the time of writing this in June 2020.

Both Planners Have

  • Personalise the cover with your choice of text
  • Multiple cover options to choose from
  • Cardstock/thin paper cover with clear plastic cover to protect it
  • Both companies do personalised notebooks as well as planners
  • Same page size at 7″ wide x 9″ high (note that the Plum Paper cover is 0.5″ wide than this – i.e. 7.5″ wide – to protect the tabs)
  • Silver coil binding
  • Colorful inside pages
  • Horizontal weekly spread (this is the layout I’ve purchased for both, but both companies have other page layouts too)
  • Dated for 12 months (you choose the start date)
  • 2 page monthly calendar with a similar layout (and both have split boxes)
  • Affordable price tag – planners in the 7″ wide x 9″ page size (the size I purchased) start at $32 USD plus shipping for both companies

Unique to Plum Paper

  • Tabs included in the cost of the planner (SHP Planners charge $10 extra for this)
  • Ships from USA
  • Monthly planning pages

Unique to SHP Planners

  • Ships from Canada

As you can see from the very short lists, there aren’t too many things that one planner has that the other planner doesn’t.

To enlarge the screen of the video, click the square icon in the bottom right hand corner of the video (it will say ‘full screen’ when you hover your mouse over the icon).

Subscribe to my YouTube channel for more planner videos!

The Cover

I like both covers but Plum Paper has more to choose from. The designs on Plum Paper’s covers are some of my favorites of any planner company – plenty of colors and styles to choose from and the color printing is always very bright and high quality. Despite not introducing different inside page color options they do regularly put out different cover designs.

Plum Paper’s cover material is tear resistant and supposedly waterproof (haven’t tested the waterproof part but it definitely doesn’t tear).

You can get interchangeable covers for the Plum Paper but all of the planners I’ve bought from them over the years have come with permanent covers so I’m not sure if you’re supposed to request your cover be interchangeable when purchasing, or you just add the interchangeable cover over the top of the existing cover and have 2 covers…

Plum Paper on the left, SHP Planners on the right

Plum Paper versus SHP Planner comparison weekly monthly spread price colors pros and cons video flipthrough pen test dupes cheaper alternative_01

Plum Paper is slightly thicker as it includes monthly planing pages and tabs / dividers for each month.

  • Plum Paper 0.75″ thick (this is with no add on pages – just the pages that come as standard in the planner.
  • SHP Planners 0.5″ thick

Plum Paper versus SHP Planner comparison weekly monthly spread price colors pros and cons video flipthrough pen test dupes cheaper alternative_02

Weekly Spreads

Plum Paper have plenty of weekly spreads to choose from. I’ve done reviews of most of them here.

SHP have less weekly spreads to choose from. Their planners come in vertical weekly, horizontal weekly, month only and teacher planners.

Holidays are not pre-printed on the weekly spread in Plum Paper however they are in the SHP Planner.

When the month ends mid-week, Plum Paper duplicates the days in the previous month and the current month. So you can choose to either plan half the week with the previous month, or move the last couple of days of the previous month onto the next month’s spread.

As you can see, some of the colors are very similar:

Plum Paper versus SHP Planner comparison weekly monthly spread price colors pros and cons video flipthrough pen test dupes cheaper alternative_07

Plum Paper versus SHP Planner comparison weekly monthly spread price colors pros and cons video flipthrough pen test dupes cheaper alternative_08

Monthly Planning

SHP Planners includes 1 lined notes page at the start of a month (before the calendar) and another lined notes page at the end of the month.

Plum Paper includes a goals and important dates page for the month, as well as 1 lined notes page before the calendar. There is another lined notes page at the end of the month.

Plum Paper versus SHP Planner comparison weekly monthly spread price colors pros and cons video flipthrough pen test dupes cheaper alternative_04

Plum Paper versus SHP Planner comparison weekly monthly spread price colors pros and cons video flipthrough pen test dupes cheaper alternative_13

Monthly Spreads

The monthly calendars are very similar – both have the traditional box format with the week starting on Monday.

Plum Paper has a lined sidebar and 1 monthly snapshot calendar, while SHP has 2 snapshot calendars and an unlined sidebar.

I prefer the placement of the holidays in the Plum Paper planner (at the bottom), SHP Planner put these in the middle of the box which wastes space.

Plum Paper versus SHP Planner comparison weekly monthly spread price colors pros and cons video flipthrough pen test dupes cheaper alternative_06

SHP Planner review horizontal weekly lined and unlined personalised custom cover simple minimalist colorful coil bound canadian alternative to plum paper erin condren_09

The Colors

The colors are similar in both planners – shades of peach, teal and green.

Plum Paper adds shades of purple while SHP has shades of light blue.

Plum Paper versus SHP Planner comparison weekly monthly spread price colors pros and cons video flipthrough pen test dupes cheaper alternative_09

Line Spacing

The line spacing is slightly different. Plum Paper is 7mm high, SHP Planners is 6mm high.

Plum Paper versus SHP Planner comparison weekly monthly spread price colors pros and cons video flipthrough pen test dupes cheaper alternative_05

Extra Pages

Plum Paper have far too many extra pages to list them all out here – I’ve done a detailed comparison in this post.

Plum Paper include these pages as standard: passwords, holidays list, 3 dot grid notes pages.

SHP Planners include these pages as standard: contacts page, lined notes page.

Plum Paper versus SHP Planner comparison weekly monthly spread price colors pros and cons video flipthrough pen test dupes cheaper alternative_03

Both of them even include similar icons on the contacts pages

Plum Paper versus SHP Planner comparison weekly monthly spread price colors pros and cons video flipthrough pen test dupes cheaper alternative_15

Both have a pocket folder at the back. Plum Paper’s is double sided while SHP’s is single sided.

Plum Paper versus SHP Planner comparison weekly monthly spread price colors pros and cons video flipthrough pen test dupes cheaper alternative_16

Pen Testing

Both planners have smooth paper that feels really nice to write on.

Plum Paper versus SHP Planner comparison weekly monthly spread price colors pros and cons video flipthrough pen test dupes cheaper alternative_20 Plum Paper versus SHP Planner comparison weekly monthly spread price colors pros and cons video flipthrough pen test dupes cheaper alternative_18

Plum Paper is less prone to ghosting and bleed through:

plum paper pen test paper quality bleed through ghosting pros and consplum paper pen test paper quality bleed through ghosting pros and cons highlighter fine tip gel

shp planner review pen testing paper quality ghosting bleed through indenting pilot frixion erasable gel fine tip ballpoint shp planner review pen testing paper quality ghosting bleed through indenting pilot frixion erasable gel fine tip ballpoint smooth paper

Which planner do I like better?

As you could probably tell in the video – I had a hard time choosing! Both have similar colors, weekly spreads, monthly calendars – even the extras pages are similar.

If I had to choose one I’d say Plum Paper. If you want tabs, it has a more affordable price tag (both companies have the same starting price but tabs are included in Plum Paper, they cost $10 extra for SHP). Plum Paper also has more cover designs and weekly spread layouts to choose from, and the paper is less prone to ghosting and bleed through. I do hope Plum Paper update their colors / style of the inside pages sometime in the near future as they’ve been using the same colors for probably 5 years now – time for a refresh!

I do still like the SHP Planner – I think the weekly spread is slightly more functional and I like the smaller line spacing so you can fit more into each day.

Still can’t decide on a planner? Browse 200+ planner reviews here.

Planning Tips

  • 50 Themes for your planner or bullet journal spreads
  • Why horizontal is my favorite weekly planner layout 
  • Using a planner key and symbols to code your planner (efficient planning methods)

Found this post helpful? Pin it!

planner comparison SHP Planners versus Plum Paper pros and cons pen testing horizontal layout which is better dupes

You may also be interested in...

  • Plum Paper Planner Comparison: Colorful versus Neutral (Which is better?)Plum Paper Planner Comparison: Colorful versus Neutral (Which is better?)
  • Plum Paper Horizontal Priorities Weekly Spread Review (Pros, Cons, Pen Test and Video)Plum Paper Horizontal Priorities Weekly Spread Review (Pros, Cons, Pen Test and Video)
  • How (and why) I pre-plan the week using the Plum Paper horizontal lined with notes layoutHow (and why) I pre-plan the week using the Plum Paper horizontal lined with notes layout
  • Review of the Ashley Shelly Planner – Weekly Planner (pros, cons and a walkthrough)Review of the Ashley Shelly Planner – Weekly Planner (pros, cons and a walkthrough)
  • SHP Planners Review (Horizontal Weekly Planner) Including Pen Testing & Video WalkthroughSHP Planners Review (Horizontal Weekly Planner) Including Pen Testing & Video Walkthrough
  • My all time favorite planner suppliesMy all time favorite planner supplies

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)

Posted In: Planner Comparisons, Planner Reviews · Tagged: alternatives to plum paper, alternatives to plum paper planner, best planner, cheap planner, cheaper alternatives to plum paper, is plum paper or shp planner best, planner dupes, planners cheaper than plum paper, planners similar to plum paper, plum paper comparison, plum paper dupes, plum paper horizontal planner, SHP horizontal planner, SHP versus Plum Paper, SHP vs. Plum paper

Welcome

Welcome to All About Planners! I’m Rachael, a 20-something Aussie addicted to graphic design and all things planning. On the blog you’ll find more than 1,000 posts about all things planning including planner reviews, tips, favorite supplies and some of my past weekly spreads.

Subscribe and join 60,000+ others on the quest to find planner peace!

Follow Me

  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • YouTube

Search

Subscribe

free printables library sign up all about planners blog image graphic subscribe

Shop At Etsy

The photos and content on this site are the property of All About Planners. They are not allowed to be used without permission from All About Planners.

Categories

Recent Posts

  • Artful Agenda Digital Planner review
  • Peter Pauper Press Essentials Dot Matrix Notebook Review (Including Pen Test)
  • ARC Punch versus Happy Planner versus the Levenger 1-2-3 Punch: Which is better?
  • Clever Fox Planner Pro Weekly Review
  • Simple Christmas themed weekly spread with washi tape and stencils

Disclaimer

All About Planners is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com.

Popular Posts

  • 130+ functional ideas to use blank notes pages of your planner or an empty notebook
  • Setting up a new planner: 70 Tasks to add
  • Planner Organization: How to color-code your planner so you’ll actually use it effectively
  • Bullet Journal Ideas: 26 Weekly Spread Layouts to Try
  • 100 things to put in your habit tracker of your planner or bullet journal (plus free printable habit tracker)

Printables

  • Learn How to Make Printables
  • How to Make Planner Stickers
  • Resources & Tools I Recommend

Subscribe to access the free Printables library

Follow Me

  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • YouTube
Privacy

Copyright © 2021 All About Planners · Theme by 17th Avenue