• HOME
  • Planning
    • Planner Newbie
      • New to planning? Start here
    • Planning Tips & Inspiration
    • 52 Planning Systems in 52 Weeks
      • My weekly spreads
    • Planner Reviews
      • Horizontal Weekly
      • Horizontal 1 Page Weekly + Notes
      • Vertical Weekly
      • Hourly Planners
      • Categories Weekly
      • Daily Planners
      • Discbound Planners
      • Teacher Planners
      • Planner Roundups
      • Happy Planner (MAMBI)
      • Budget Planners
      • Undated Daily Planners
      • Undated Weekly
    • Planner Index
    • Planner Comparisons
    • Bullet Journal
      • Bullet Journal Reviews
      • Bullet Journal Spreads
      • Bullet Journal Tips
    • Planner pens
    • Highlighters
    • Planner Stickers
    • Digital Planning
    • Household Binder
    • Stationery Shopping
    • Rachael’s Favorites
    • Blogging & Online Business
  • Graphic Design
    • Photoshop Tutorials
    • Affinity Publisher
    • Microsoft Word
    • Microsoft Excel
    • Canva
    • Silhouette Studio
    • PicMonkey
  • SHOP
    • Shop at Etsy
    • Online Store
    • Graphic Design Resources
    • ECOURSES
    • Ebooks
      • 54 Mistakes Etsy Sellers Make (And How to Fix Them)
      • 1200 Blog Post Ideas
        • 1200 Blog Post Ideas (Exclusive Download Content)
      • 200 Blog Post Title Prompts (For Any Type of Blog)
        • 200 Blog Post Title Prompts (Exclusive Download Content)
    • Feedback & Testimonials
    • Planner Supplies (my sister’s shop!)
    • Shop my favorite planner supplies on Amazon
  • Learn
    • ECOURSES
      • Free Graphic Design Video Tutorials Library
      • Printables in Affinity Publisher
      • How to Make Planner Stickers
      • How to Make Printables in Photoshop
      • Printables in Microsoft Word
      • Printables in Microsoft Excel
      • Digital planners and notebooks in Microsoft PowerPoint
      • How to Make Labels in Photoshop
      • Make Patterns in Photoshop
      • Party Printables
      • How to Write Product Descriptions
    • Ebooks
      • 54 Mistakes Etsy Sellers Make (And How to Fix Them)
      • 200 Blog Post Title Prompts (For Any Type of Blog)
      • 1200 Blog Post Ideas
  • FREE
    • FREE Printables
    • Free Printables Library – Subscribers Login
  • Travel
    • Travel Planning
    • Europe
    • Australia & New Zealand
  • About
    • Browse All Posts
    • FAQ
      • What is a Printable? What happens when I purchase a printable from you?
      • Printing Tips
      • Printable Planner Stickers
      • Downloading Files
      • How to Open Zipped File Folders
      • What does EDITABLE mean?
      • Monogram Etiquette

All About Planners

Printable planners to organize your home, business and life!

August 22, 2018

7 Planner supplies that aren’t worth the hype

I’ve done a lot of research over the years trying lots of different planner supplies… these are 7 planner supplies that (I think) don’t live up to the hype!

This post contains affiliate links.

1. Expensive highlighters

Most highlighters are in the same color shade, regardless of price (with the exception of a few which I’ll mention below). I’ve purchased many dupes over the years to compare whether it was worth spending extra, and most of the time, I don’t think it is.

Here’s a good example of a cheap dupe (Officework’s own brand J Burrows) versus the well known Stabilo Boss. If I hadn’t written the brand names, would you be able to tell the difference?

stabilo boss pastel versus j burrows officeworks australia cheap versus expensive highlighters dupe alternative recommended swatches bullet journal

The exception to this for me, is the Zebra Mildliners. It took me a while to buy these as they are far more expensive than most highlighters but they do come in colors that are hard to find. Sometimes you just need a highlighter that isn’t neon or pastel. The Mildliner colors are more unique and that’s where I think it’s justified to spend a bit extra on the Mildliners.

You can buy them individually so if you only want the unique colors try their teal, apple green, orange, light grey and red.

zebra mildliners review swatches ghosting bleed through bullet journal planner supplies dual tip highlighter zebra mildliner highlighter review ghosting bleed through swatches quality test dual tip cheaper alternatives

If you don’t want to invest in the Mildliners, see this post for some other options: 4 Similar (and cheaper) alternatives to the Zebra Mildliner Dual Tip Highlighters

2. Jumbo packs of gel pens off Amazon

No you don’t need 36, 48 or 100 etc. packs of pens that have 10 different shades of pink. Instead, save your money and invest in quality pens where the ink doesn’t skip, they write smoothly and the colors are vibrant.

Related: My Top 3 All-Time Favorite Gel Pens

3. Scribbles that Matter notebook

Sure it has a cute cover, but the paper had bad pen ghosting. For all the hype I expected better quality paper.

The pages near the stitching seams lay flat but the ones between not so much. There’s already a hint that the stitching is going to come undone over time.

I feel this notebook is a case of paying double the price of any other generic dot grid notebook purely for the cover and built in pen loop. The paper quality / amount of pen bleed through is basically the same as many other (cheaper) dot grid notebooks I’ve done pen testing in (see more than 50 of my bullet journal notebooks reviews here).

See the full review of the Scribbles That Matter notebook in this post.

scribbles that matter notebook review pros and cons bullet journal pen testing bleed through index page number paper quality worth the money where to buy from

scribbles that matter pen test review highlighter gel fine tip ballpoint bleed through stamp ghosting a5 bujo notebook pros and cons video

scribbles that matter notebook review journal pros and cons worth the cost where to buy bullet journal essentials hype notebook a5 grid dot minimalist

scribbles that matter bullet journal notebook review tombow brush pens testing bleed through ghosting paper quality swatches

Instead of the scribbles that matter, try these notebooks:

  • Vivid Scribbles Dot Grid Notebook (bleedproof 140GSM paper!)
  • Archer and Olive Dot Grid Notebook (Is the 160 GSM Paper Worth the Hype?)
  • Dingbats* Notebook for Bullet Journaling Review (super smooth paper!)
  • Slow Journal (160 GSM paper)

4. Icon Stencils

I saw this stencil and thought great, a cheap alternative to planner stickers! However, the cut outs of the shapes are too close together. It’s quite difficult to get a pen in there. I can really only use the symbols in this stencil.

So if you’re looking for a stencil, be sure to check the size and see if there’s a photo someone’s taken of what the shapes look like on paper.

planner stencil using codes to plan your day minimalist planning color coding bullet journaling simple weekly spread plan with me essential planner supplies-min

5. Expensive Washi Tape

I really don’t understand the current craze of washi tape that costs $6 + per roll… and then people buying rolls of that tape for the sole purpose of cutting it up into washi samples to try and make a quick buck (doesn’t it lose it’s stickiness after someone else has put their fingers all over it?)… and then people paying a ridiculous price for those washi samples.

I’m all for splurging on things you really want (I’ll admit I’ve bought a roll or 2 of expensive high quality Doodlebug washi tape which I’ve used here, here and here. But multiple rolls of expensive washi tape… you don’t need it.

washi tape addiction best washi tape for planners doodlebug color coding thin washi tape carefully crafted planner supplies-min

Related post: My all time favorite washi tapes (and how I organize them)

6. Kikki K Pens

… And most Kikki K things to be honest. I really only buy kikki k notepads and the occasional planner from there nowadays. It’s all gotten a bit tacky looking but still over-priced.

The Kikki K write in rainbow pens are needle tip so if you write on an angle like I do, the ink is prone to skipping. The yellow is also near impossible to see on the page, although this is the case for most yellow pens 🙁 Otherwise the colors are nice, but there’s plenty of other pen brands that do pens in nice colors and write well.

So basically, just because something is by a well known brand, doesn’t mean it’s automatically going to be amazing.

The Ooly ‘just write’ gel pens are very similar to the Kikki K Write in Rainbow pens: 

ooly gel pens 0.4mm fine tip rainbow colors similar to kikki k needle tip planner supplies stationery review haul color coding rainbow pen pack affordable zulilly haul

Related: Ooly pen & highlighters haul (cute rainbow planner supplies) 

7. Erin Condren

Yes Erin Condren stuff is nice.. but $50 – $65 USD for a planner plus $40 USD to ship it to Australia is really expensive. It’s great that they let you customise the cover, but many planner companies offer this nowadays.

Just about every well-known planner company these days has vertical, horizontal and hourly layouts like Erin Condren but for a much cheaper price.

erin condren vertical life planner hardbound version review pros and cons categorised neutral colors comparison with hourly

Related: Similar and Cheaper Alternatives to the Erin Condren Life Planner 

50 tips for writing a better to do list productivity time management organization planning get stuff done beat procrastination

More planning tips

  • 5 Planner Supplies I Don’t Use (And Why)
  • 5 Planner supplies you should never skimp on
  • Planning on a budget: If I only had $50 to spend on planner supplies, this is what I’d buy

Planner Reviews

  • Agendio Review (custom, personalised weekly planner) 
  • Ashley Shelly Planner Review – Weekly Planner 
  • Amy Knapp’s Family Organizer Planner Review

Browse all 500+ posts on the blog!

Found this post helpful? Pin it!

planner supplies that aren't worth the hype overpriced erin condren mildliner highlighters supplies stencils bullet journal tips

You may also be interested in...

  • 10 Planner supplies that will help you plan your week faster10 Planner supplies that will help you plan your week faster
  • My all time favorite planner suppliesMy all time favorite planner supplies
  • 50 Tips for Getting the Most Out of Your Planner50 Tips for Getting the Most Out of Your Planner
  • Using blank pages: 50 useful lists to add to your plannerUsing blank pages: 50 useful lists to add to your planner
  • Answers to 50 Frequently Asked Planner Questions (Planning FAQ’s)Answers to 50 Frequently Asked Planner Questions (Planning FAQ’s)
  • 6 Useful ways to efficiently plan your week using highlighters6 Useful ways to efficiently plan your week using highlighters

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)

Posted In: Planning Tips & Inspiration · Tagged: all about planners, best planner pens, best planner supplies, best washi tape, blogs about planning, favorite planner supplies, favorite planning tools, favorite washi tape brand, must have planner supplies, overrated planner supplies, planner addict, planner addiction, planner essentials, planner life, planner necesseties, planner recommendation, planner supplies that aren't worth the hype, planner supplies you don't need, planning must have, planning tips

Comments

  1. Helen Knight says

    August 22, 2018 at 20:24

    I 100% agree with all of these!

  2. Dee says

    August 23, 2018 at 00:20

    You’re brave enough to add Condren! I never understood the hype. They’re beautiful and it’s nice they can be personalized but there’s many, many other options.

Welcome

Welcome to All About Planners! I’m Rachael, a 20-something Aussie addicted to graphic design and all things planning. On the blog you’ll find more than 1,000 posts about all things planning including planner reviews, tips, favorite supplies and some of my past weekly spreads.

Subscribe and join 60,000+ others on the quest to find planner peace!

Follow Me

  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • YouTube

Search

Subscribe

free printables library sign up all about planners blog image graphic subscribe

Shop At Etsy

The photos and content on this site are the property of All About Planners. They are not allowed to be used without permission from All About Planners.

Categories

Recent Posts

  • Blue Themed weekly spread in the Plum Paper Quad Lined layout
  • Why I buy paper planners when I could create my own
  • Sprouted Planner Review (Dashboard Layout Weekly Planner)
  • Which discs are compatible with Plum Paper’s disc punched planners?
  • Hacking the Dabney Lee for Blue Sky Horizontal Weekly Planner

Disclaimer

All About Planners is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com.

Popular Posts

  • 50 Tips for writing a better to do list that will make you more productive
  • How I use Excel to organize all my travel plans (research, itinerary, hotel, tours, bookings, packing list etc.)
  • How I use Excel to Organize a Home Renovation (budget, spending, program, paint colors, contacts, quotes)
  • After trying 52 planners, these were my top 7 favorite weekly planners
  • Blue Themed weekly spread in the Plum Paper Quad Lined layout

Printables

  • Learn How to Make Printables
  • How to Make Planner Stickers
  • Resources & Tools I Recommend

Follow Me

  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • YouTube
Privacy

Copyright © 2022 All About Planners · Theme by 17th Avenue